iBook overhaul leads to frustration as well as success
I finally got round to undertaking the incredibly complicated and scary technical job I’ve been talking and writing about for weeks now. Yesterday I took my old Apple Dual USB G3 500MHz white iBook to pieces, removed the 10Gb hard drive and busted CD-R it came with originally, and replaced them with a 40Gb Samsung hard drive and a Sony CD-RW/DVD drive before putting the iBook back together again.
I followed the instructions I downloaded in PDF format from ifixit.com to the letter, and have Hayes to thank for pointing me in the direction of that enormously useful website in the first place.
I’m not great when it comes to organisation under most circumstances but I knew if I so much as slipped up once, I could destroy the computer and waste a lot of money spent on new parts, so every screw that came out was immediately taped to a sheet of paper. This meant, by the time I’d completely taken the iBook apart, I had a sequential set of screws as well as other bits and pieces such as springs and rubber feet.
All I had to do – ha, all I had to do, I say! – when putting the machine back together again was to follow the instructions, and the line-up of screws and bits, in reverse order. I also covered the screen with a tea-towel to avoid scratching it while pulling up boards and teasing out tiny screws, which were liable to take flight across the kitchen, and often did.
The job took me around two-and-a-half hours, not including breaks, which was half an hour less than most Apple-related websites said it should take and so at least three hours less than I expected given I have never, ever attempted anything like this before.
I discovered during the process that a spring mechanism in the battery compartment had been missing since I bought the iBook from where it should be. I found it inside the casing. There had always been a dark spot on the undercasing, too, which turned out to be a tiny gap in the inside white paintwork. I fixed that with a dab of matt household paint, the kind you put on walls and skirting boards. Sloppy work, Apple! I also learned that laptops are mostly held together by tinfoil and tape, once you get past the outer shielding. I couldn’t help thinking, all the time I was disembowelling the iBook, of those dream homes people buy that turn out to be have damp, dodgy wiring and bugs behind the smooth interior walls. We pay thousands of pounds for computers and they’re held together by a few screws, some string and spit.
The new combo drive works and the new hard disk is identified as functioning by the Apple Hardware Diagnostics CD I used to test everything before attempting to install OS 9. That’s where I hit a wall of frustration and anger. The Drive Setup program won’t even acknowledge the new hard drive is there, so I can’t initialise (format) it and therefore can’t get the operating system onto the machine. I took the entire iBook apart and put it back together – again, and in less than an hour second time round – to check the connections on the hard drive were as they should be, before I discovered an online database of Mac-compatible drives with user reviews. Turns out the drive is entirely compatible – which I knew, as any 2.5-inch laptop hard drive would be okay so long as it matched the dimensions overall – and lots of people have installed it successfully on iBooks and PowerBooks. The thing I noted was that none had installed the drive using anything earlier than the latest Mac OS X (known as Tiger).
As I see it, there are two possibilities here: one is that I need to install OS X Tiger, which I will very soon thanks to the help and generosity of a friend overseas who shall remain nameless here but s/he knows who s/he is, and has my gratitute for their kind assistance. The other is that the drive came to me busted, which is unlikely but I will know within a week or so for certain and it will still be returnable if it is kaput. And I won’t feel quite so daunted if I have to open up the iBook a third and fourth time (once to remove the drive to send it back, then again to install a replacement). I hope it doesn’t come to that, of course!
Apparently, the latest versions of OS X are much, much better at playing nicely with components not approved by Apple. Good job. I can only assume Apple saw sense in realising that if you want to get Windows users on board (or in my case, back on board), you have to be a little less parochial with these things – plus, a DIY-restored Apple computer is better, surely, than Apple computers going on the scrapheap or into the attic? I mean, once this iBook is up and running, I’ll be sat in coffee shops displaying that Apple logo while I type. All Apple portable users are advertisements for the company when out and about, so it hardly matters what age the machine is or what components are inside it.
The bottom line is I learned a lot and am very proud of myself for having the guts to get at the er, guts, of the iBook and save in excess of £200 in labour costs. I am also incredibly frustrated for the time being to have an upgraded, restored machine that is about as much use as a breakfast tray until I can get its brains onboard. I have to keep reminding myself that this project isn’t a disaster and has gone very well so far.
20 comments on “iBook overhaul leads to frustration as well as success”
September 28th, 2006 at 2:19 pm
Congratulations on your progress! Howard sent me your frustrations about the Hard Drive. I saw Lorne sent you an e-mail with some ideas on the solving the problem. He seems to know a little bit more about that, as he replaced the HD in his old iMac years ago. I don’t have too much knowledge in this area. I hope the Tiger DVD will solve your problems there! I am glad that between the three of us here we have been able to be of some help to you.
Sounds like you found the whole process of tearing the iBook apart as rewarding as I did when I took Dan’s apart. It’s a real sense of accomplishment to be able to say that you took something that complicated apart and got it back together, and still have it working!
September 28th, 2006 at 3:43 pm
I’m praying the Tiger DVD solves the problem! If it doesn’t, the hard drive has to go back. It was really nice of Lorne to write me back, and to go to such helpful lengths. I really appreciated his advice. And yes, I found it actually quite fun - okay, it’s geeky but you’ve got to, um, have some balls to attempt the job and it kind of gives you confidence. x
September 28th, 2006 at 4:09 pm
Sits and looks on in awe - I would never dare even open mine up!
September 28th, 2006 at 5:26 pm
I’d cross my fingers that OS X 10.4 does the trick for you as well, but I’m typing and all of this would end up as unreadable junk.
September 28th, 2006 at 7:47 pm
As it has in some of your comments on my site Howard
September 28th, 2006 at 10:20 pm
Hahaha! D says, can’t you type with your nose? x
September 29th, 2006 at 7:30 pm
As big as my Romanesque nose it, I’m afraid that it would cause as much chaos as crossing my fingers.
September 29th, 2006 at 7:50 pm
Ah you need to do what I’m doing now and cross your toes!!!
Congrats on a job well done, no bits missing, I guess the cats didn’t help you :-p toes crossed that the OS X 10.4 does sort the problem out for you
September 29th, 2006 at 8:12 pm
Willow, if you’re typing with your toes, I hope you’ve painted them prettily before gracing this blog!
The cats - even Dru - were exceptionally well-behaved and didn’t pester me once. One or two occasionally came to look, and puzzle, and ask me questions which to my ears sounded like ‘meow’ and ‘rowr’. And then they’d shrug their little pussy shoulders and leave me to it.
Yeah, my mysterious benefactor’s DVD will be here soon. I’ve camped out under the letterbox waiting for the postie with a hip flask full of brandy, a Matrix graphic novel and thermal undies which reach down to the knees and are unbelievably unsexy accoutrements bought by my mother one Christmas two years ago for me. Hey, it gets cold at the front door!
(Am I joking? you ask. Will I tell? No.)
If the DVD doesn’t find the hard drive, they will hear my scream from Calcutta and the iBook will fly through the air so hard it will give a concussion to a preacher in Texas. And that might not necessarily be a bad thing. x
September 29th, 2006 at 8:21 pm
he he he … truly hope it does the trick :o)
While my toes are prettily painted they’re crossed under the table, I’m typing with my fingers … never tried to do with my toes and long as they are I don’t think it would work lol
September 29th, 2006 at 8:27 pm
Are we talking freakishly long like the Martians’ fingers in War of the Worlds? We could sell you to the carnival!
Don’t worry, We’re skint at the moment but we won’t sell our friends to the slave trade. Or the entertainment trade. Um, both being kind of the same thing… x
September 29th, 2006 at 8:54 pm
lol thanks … I think lol
No not freakishly … just that my second toe is longer than my big toe (I probably could do two toe typing!) I’ve been told that it means one/both of two things … celtish heritage and/or that I’m a witch …. duh lol
September 29th, 2006 at 9:25 pm
It depends on the type of ’slave’ trade you’re talking about.
September 30th, 2006 at 10:52 am
Well there’s the guy in the basement. But we don’t talk about him publicly. x
September 30th, 2006 at 10:53 am
Willow, yeah. If that’s supposed to be true… It’s certainly true for you… x
October 2nd, 2006 at 11:11 am
THE IBOOK IS ALIVE, I TELL YOU! ALIVE! ALIVE!
Mac OS X 10.3 Tiger DVD in drive… New hard disk recognised immediately… Currently installing nice, shiny new OS….
HURRAH!!!! I can fix computers. How hardcore geek is that?
:-))))))))))))))))))))))
October 2nd, 2006 at 10:51 pm
YEAH
** Go Spicy ** Go Spicy ** Go Spicy**
Nice one mate, you may be a geek but you’re a goth geek :-p
(ducks and runs for cover he he he)
October 3rd, 2006 at 8:49 am
Goth geek! Humph! I did dye my hair a few weeks back and it was supposed to be dark brown but turned out closer to black. I don’t like it as I’m too pale with dark hair… But it will fade… As has my youth, hahahaha! x
March 21st, 2007 at 4:26 pm
[...] guide. Apple iBook G3 Dual-USB (White)”Pimped-up” iBook: hard drive replacement instructions. Apple iBook G3 Dual-USB 500MHz WhiteOverhaul leads to frustration as well as success. How to take the notebook to pieces, remove the [...]
August 17th, 2007 at 8:00 am
[...] helpful pictures. Apple iBook G3 Clamshell (Indigo)Bezel modification for new optical drive. Apple iBook G3 Dual-USB 500MHz WhiteOverhaul leads to frustration as well as success. How to take the notebook to pieces, remove the [...]
have your say
You must be logged in to post a comment. Registration is free, and easy.